By John Kirn
To the Editor,
It is impossible for us, as humans, to avoid having some impact on our
environment and the other organisms in it. This is true regardless of whether
or not we eat meat or use
animal-based products. This paper was once a tree. So we have to weigh
the cost and benefits of all our actions. Your article focused on the use
of animals in research, with little
reference to what the animals are used for. This is clearly a justifiable
news item, particularly since some were not aware that animal research
is conducted here. One point of clarification; "animal testers" can also
refer to folks in the cosmetics industry. I can assure that all this type
of research is not done at Wesleyan. However, such a limited focus provides
about as much information about boilogy as an article about pigments informs
us about Picasso. It is unfortunate that the product of our craft as scientists
often does not produce the kind of immediate appreciation or understanding
in nonscientists by examining a work of art. Nevertheless, there is beauty
in science for those with a little patience. Moreover, it is becoming more
important every day for all to gain a better understanding of science,
as potential benefits (and risks) of biotechnology increase. To this end
I encourage all to take more courses in the natural sciences. This would
provide a basis for evaluating, for example, whether or not an animal feels
pain after part of the brain is destroyed. This might also blur the ethical
distinction between eating plants and animals (both groups have very complex
sensory systems which they use to respond to their environment). I am not
implying that more science would make vivisection an easier issue to deal
with or that one needs to be scientifically literate to have high moral
standards. However, as with any debate, a common language is essential.
Even if scientific literacy does not change a person’s ethiical concerns
about difficult issues like animal research, at least he/she will understand
why the research is being done. Who knows, after a few more bio courses,
some students might be inspired to help us devise novel research strategies
that reduce the need for animal research in the future. They may even develop
an eye for the beauty in biology along the way.
Kirn is an Assistant Professor of Biology at Wesleyan.
|