The Walter MacNaughten Memorial Award is presented by the Class of 1900 in recognition of Outstanding Baseball Achievement.
2012 Joe Giaimo
2011 The Seniors
2010 Brice Kelly
2009 Drew Dominguez
2008 Chris Simpson
2007 Chris Graceffa
2006 Jeff Maier
2005 Mac Clonan
2004 Tom Bloss
2003 William Robinson
2002 Will James & David Bushnell
2001 William Robinson
2000 Michael Volpe
1999 Brett Matthews
1998 Jonathan P. Epstein
1997 Scott M. Hevesy
1996 Jesse B. Carpenter
1995 Jed D. Hoyer
1994 Craig S. Brewer
1993 Mark A. Woodworth
1992 Mark J. Consorte
1991 John W. Hurley & Samuel L. Player
1990 Glenn A. Frankel
1989 "The Seniors"
1988 James C. Maynard
1987 Mark A. Borkman
1986 Mark W. Hill
1985 Joseph P. Grasso
1984 Robert C. Barringer
1983 Todd S. Mogren
1982 Douglad P. Mannen
1981 Mark P. Anderson & Tom J. Miceli
1980 James E. McGarry
1979 Patrick K. Kiley & Robert D. Sansone
1978 Kevin Rose
1977 Bradley M. Vanacore
1976 Alan G. Poon
1975 David Durian & Richard L. Burpee
1974 Richard L. Burpee
1973 Kie N. Westby
1972 Peter J. Hicks
1971 Michael D. Kishbauch
1970 Frank T. Waters III
1969 James L Martello
1968 Stephen R. Horvat Jr.
1967 Jacques W. Legette
1966 Jeffrey A. Hopkins
1965 Philip L. Rockwell
1964 Peter Sipples
1963 Steven R. Humphrey
1962 Edward I. Berry III
1961 M. Bradley Beechen