(click on an opponent's name to see the all-time game-by-game results)
| Opponent | W-L-T | First Met | Last Met | Last Wes Win | Last Opp Win | Current Win Streak | Greatest Wes Win | Greatest Opp Win |
| Amherst | 41-68-9 | 1882 | 2012 | 2002, 14-13 | 2012, 17-9 |
Amherst, 10 in a row | 1888, 54-0 | 1925, 73-6 |
| Bates | 27-4-0 | 1923 | 2012 | 2012, 24-22 |
2005, 30-29 (OT) | Wesleyan, 7 in a row | 1992, 49-6 | 2004, 28-7 |
| Bowdoin | 54-29-2 | 1906 | 2012 | 2012, 34-14 |
2011, 12-6 | Wesleyan, 1 in a row | 1966, 39-0 | 1935, 33-0 |
| Colby | 18-17-0 | 1927 | 2012 | 2012, 31-28 |
2009, 16-13 (OT) | Wesleyan, 3 in a row | 1976, 38-0 | 1989, 39-6 |
| Hamilton | 24-17-1 | 1909 | 2012 | 2012, 34-14 |
2011, 7-6 |
Wesleyan, 1 in a row | 1918, 52-0 | 1986, 64-7 |
| Middlebury | 23-20-2 | 1907 | 2011 | 2011, 16-15 | 2010, 24-21 | Wesleyan, 1 in a row | 1967, 39-0 | 1970, 49-21 |
| Trinity | 52-59-1 | 1885 | 2012 | 2000, 37-13 | 2012, 30-24 (OT) |
Trinity, 12 in a row | 1887, 58-0 | 2005, 63-7 |
| Tufts | 21-22-2 | 1892 | 2012 | 2012, 35-14 |
2008, 20-14 | Wesleyan, 2 in a row | 2004, 37-7 | 1983, 42-16 |
| Williams | 37-76-5 | 1881 | 2012 | 1999, 33-28 | 2012, 19-7 |
Williams, 13 in a row | 1900, 35-0 | 1973, 44-0 |