|
Contextualizing Literature on the Web:
An Interview with Antonio González
Antonio González,
Romance Languages and Literatures |
by Dan Schnaidt
December 2000
Dan Schnaidt, ACM for the Arts and Humanities, interviews Professor
Antonio González of Romance Languages and Literatures about
his course Web site and its usefulness in teaching
literature.
On your web site you present
Spanish223 as a study of modern literature "in it's historical
context and in relation to other artistic expressions, especially
painting." Before you developed the web site, how did you provide
this kind of historical context?
Before I constructed the web site the
students didn't have as much context.. . . .mainly what I would
tell them in class or excerpts from manuals that I would
photocopy. As far as images go, it depended on my level of energy
to get slides, screen and projector; it was a huge time
investment.
|
Reading is always a critical
performance. And I would like to include in another more
specialized course, perhaps on Lorca, assignments for students to
go into the recording booth and create this kind of critical performance
|
Why focus on painting? Among all
the arts, is there a special relationship between literature and
painting?
From a pedagogical point of view, it's
particularly useful. Students relate to the visual more
immediately than to other artistic expressions. I should be clear
that my treatment is not what you would get in an art history
class. Half way through the semester The students read Ortega y
Gassett's essay "Concerning Point of View in the Arts," which
focuses on the relationship between painting and philosophy at
crucial junctures. Although I don't use it exclusively,
Ortegas approach helps us to focus the relationship between
literature and painting in a very particular way.
Ortega conceptualizes history by
comparing it to a movie made up of a series of stills on film.
Using the tool of phenomenology, he telescopes history through
this series of stills. What we need to do is find those special
stills that help us to understand historical evolution in a
general sense. I base the course on this notion while emphasizing
to my students that there are many other ways of conceptualizing
history.
For each author, you've written a
short essay or reading guide, which helps to create historical
context. Each guide is followed by a list of themes and questions.
How does all of this come together in the
course?
I draw on those themes to structure the
discussion in class. The way for the students to best understand
the reading is to have the reading guides and questions next to
them, and to use the questions to motivate their reading so that
reading [of the assigned text] becomes something of a
detective-like search of specific information.
At the end of the Espronceda
reading guide is your" Introduction to the Analysis of Poetry."
Are there other critical aides like this? If so, how
important is an understanding of analytical methods for students
at this level
In the guide to Moratin I inserted a very
elementary discussion of Aristotelian poetics as it was understood
in the neo-classical era. These materials are there for the
students to use when they are appropriate. It is significant to
understand a little bit about Aristotle's dramatic unities when
they read Moratin's play. It's significant, once again, to
understand the basic concepts of poetic analysis when they start
reading the poetry. But I wouldn't want to front-load too much of
that stuff in this particular course.
There are over 200 poems on the web
site. Is the act of reading poetry on a screen fundamentally
different than reading it on the printed page
The act of reading on the web is crucial
for the course. An example is the way context is provided for
Antonio Machado. The image [that accompanies "Hacia un ocaso
radiante..."] of the "noria," a primitive well used
still in the 20th, is crucial for understanding the symbolism of
this cultural artifact in Machados poetry. A wheel holding
buckets is put into action by a horse or donkey that circles
around the well pushing a pole. These physical circular patterns
are directly related to the circularity of being in time and of
cultural traditions as Machado views them.
You accompany another Machado poem,
"Retrato," with a half-dozen images and a rendition in song by
Joan Manuel Serrat. The song, images and the text combine, for me,
as a type of critical performance. Does this point toward new
critical methods that are only possible on the web? If so, will
you ask students to create similar work?
Yes. Reading is always a critical
performance. And I would like to include in another more
specialized course, perhaps on Lorca, assignments for students to
go into the recording booth and create this kind of critical
performance. In the short term, there are still a lot of
logistical problems, but this is my long term goal for teaching
literature.
Do you have plans to include video
on your site?
Buñuel made a movie in the 1950s
based on the 19th C novel "Tristana" by Benito
Pérez Galdós. Students now see the movie in class.
It would be useful to isolate a scene or two and put them on the
web as a place to discuss the relationship between writing and
film as art forms.
Can there be too much? Is there a
point at which media intended to in some way enlarge a work of art
can start to distract from or even displace it?
People do sometimes run astray of the
centrality of the written word. But tools in and of themselves are
not too much; it depends on how faculty use them.
The Span223 site includes over 2500
images. Sheer number tells us you believe there is a strong iconic
component to learning. Would you say that text has been overly
privileged in undergraduate study of
literature?
I hesitate to put it in those terms. I
will say that often literature is not contextualized enough
&emdash; at the level of deep contextualization that Ortega speaks
of, at the level of the philosophical and ideological basis that
art and literature share.
What would you like to add that I'm
leaving out?
Maps. In addition to geographic context,
maps help to illustrate geopolitical and thematic concerns and
make them more accessible to our students. Since most of our
students have not been to Spain, bringing Spain visually to them
is crucial. Take Unamuno's theme of the centrality of Castile
within the framework of the Spanish national identity. If you look
on a map you can see the wedged-shape of the Castilian-speaking
area of the Iberian peninsula, the result of Castiles role
in leading the reconquest of Spain from the Muslims during the
Middle Ages.
|