| |
Types of Sources
In libraries and on the Internet you can find books, magazines,
encyclopedias, lab reports, historical documents, audio and video
recordings, and all sorts of other information sources, all of which
are useful for different purposes. Deciding which will suit your
purpose is an important early step in the research process.
Three basic types of resources - To know where to go for
information, it is useful to know how information is produced; here
is a very general overview. (note that these are not rigid
distinctions; the same resource can overlap categories.)
- Primary - Direct, uninterpreted records of the
subject of your research project. A primary source is as close as
you can get to the event, person, phenomenon, or other subject of your
research. As such, a primary
source can be almost anything, depending on the subject
and purpose of your research. There is no clear or set line between primary and secondary
sources; it depends on the purpose and perspective of your research
project. For example, a philosopher studying ideas would want the
last or latest edition of a writer's work as a primary source to make
a philosophical analysis of a developed idea, whereas an intellectual
historian studying the development of ideas would want previous
editions and drafts, the writer's notes, and the writer's own sources
to see how an idea developed. Or, a published version (or even a
translation) of a diary, if it is a reliable representation of the
actual diary, is for many (but not all) purposes sufficient as a
primary source. So be creative in thinking of possible relevant primary sources
of information on your topic.
- Secondary - Books, articles, and other
writings by scholars and researchers build on primary
sources by interpreting and assessing primary
information.
- Tertiary - Encyclopedias, indexes, textbooks,
and other reference sources which present summaries of or
introductions to the current state of research on a
topic, or provide a list of primary and secondary sources
of more extensive information.
Work backwards. Usually, your research should begin with
tertiary sources:
- Tertiary - Start by finding background information on
your topic by consulting reference sources for introductions and
summaries, and to find bibliographies or citations of secondary
and primary sources.
- Secondary - Find books, articles, and other sources
providing more extensive and thorough analyses of a topic. Check
to see what other scholars have to say about your topic.
- Primary - A primary source
on its own is likely only a snippet or snapshot of the full picture;
thus it is often difficult to interpret on its own. Reference sources
and secondary analyses give you a framework for interpreting primary
sources. But the real work of research is examining primary sources
to test the interpretations, analyses, and views you find in
reference and secondary sources. Now that you have a solid background knowledge
of your topic, you are better able to understand, interpret, and analyze
the primary source information. Use primary sources to find evidence
which challenges these interpretations, or evidence in favor of one
scholar's interpretation over that of another; then posit an
interpretation of your own, and look for more primary sources for
evidence to confirm or refute your thesis. When you present your
conclusions, you will have produced another secondary source to aid
others in their research.
Here's a brief list of some of the sources you can find in each of
these categories; remember, there are many more:
Primary
- Conference proceedings - Scholars and researchers
getting together and presenting their latest ideas and
findings
- Books - Extensive and detailed discussions of a
particular topic or set of topics, written by the scholars and
researchers who came up with the ideas or discovered the
findings.
- Journal articles - Brief, specific analyses of
particular aspects of a topic, written by the scholars and
researchers who came up with the ideas or discovered the
findings.
- Lab reports - Experiments, observations, etc.
- Historical documents - Official papers, maps, treaties,
etc.
- First-person accounts - Diaries, memoirs, letters,
interviews, speeches
- Recordings - audio, video, photographic
- Artifacts - manufactured items such as clothing,
furniture, tools, buildings
- Newspapers - Some types of articles, e.g. stories on a
breaking issue, or journalists reporting the results of their
investigations.
- Government publications - Census statistics, economic
data, court reports, etc.
- Internet - Web sites that publish the author's findings
or research; e.g. your professor's home page listing research
results. Note: use extreme caution when using the Internet as a
primary source
remember, on the Internet a page citing
authoritative findings could have been published by any goofball
off the street.
- Manuscript collections - Collected writings, notes,
letters, diaries, and other unpublished works.
- Archives - Records (minutes of meetings, purchase
invoices, financial statements, etc.) of an organization (e.g. The
Nature Conservancy), institution (e.g. Wesleyan University),
business, or other group entity (even the Grateful Dead has an
archivist on staff).
Secondary
- Books - Extensive and detailed analyses by scholars
providing criticisms, commentaries, and interpretations of primary
ideas and findings.
- Journal articles - Brief, specific analyses,
criticisms, commentaries, and interpretations of particular
aspects of primary ideas and findings.
- Newspapers - Articles which report on earlier findings,
or offer commentary or opinions.
- Internet - Web sites that comment on earlier findings
or research; see cautionary note above!
Tertiary
- Encyclopedias - Articles providing introductory or
summary information; coverage can be general (e.g. Encyclopedia
Britannica) or subject-specific (e.g. Encyclopedia of
Sociology).
- Dictionaries - Definitions or brief summaries of terms,
ideas, etc.; coverage can be general (e.g. Webster's, Random
House) or subject-specific (e.g. Dictionary of Cell Biology).
- Almanacs - Good for concise factual information, e.g.
statistics, lists
- Directories - Lists of people or organizations, with
addresses, affiliations, etc.; useful guides to finding primary
source material
- Atlases - Maps of population, economic, historical,
political, geological, biological, climatological, etc.
information.
- Indexes - Lists of sources on a subject or set of
subjects; once you have some key terms for your topic, use indexes
to find secondary and primary sources.
|
|